Ellen M.
February 14th, 2026
I had my fifth baby with FMCC and it was a terrible experience. I went to the group specifically because they are a pro-life practice, but one of the midwives came in to one of my first appointments and went on and on about how high my risk was for having a baby with Down syndrome. She knew I already had a child with Down syndrome and seemed panicked on my behalf. It would seem it never occurred to her that I might not consider a baby with Down syndrome a tragedy. I emailed Dr. Stroud directly to tell him about the situation and how upsetting it was and I never heard a word back from him.
When I was in labor, the midwife who was managing my care broke my water, said I went from 3-4 cm to 5 cm while she was breaking my water, and then LEFT THE HOSPITAL to go home and take a shower. This was my fifth baby and I did not have an epidural. Needless to say, she completely missed the birth and some random doctor I’d never met before who happened to be walking down the hall delivered my baby.
Then that doctor billed me for the delivery *and* FMCC billed me for the delivery, which was a headache to deal with. Over the entirety of my prenatal care I was overcharged by FMCC by about $800 and I was not reimbursed for 19 months.
These are only the most egregious examples of issues I encountered with FMCC. I highly recommend looking elsewhere for your prenatal care. I am sure Dr. and Mrs. Stroud are devoutly pro-life, but it does not appear that they have hired people with their same convictions nor their skill level.
Aubrey Dettmer
January 6th, 2026
Dr. Stroud and his team helped us battle primary and secondary infertility by finding the root causes and treating them through NaPro technology. We are forever grateful for our beautiful children with thanks to this skilled team. When I needed repeat c-sections (the first was through a different provider, and I chose not to do a vbac due to other medical conditions), Dr. Stroud’s team showed me the huge difference in a gentle c-section. I was able to see my babies through a clear drape, hold them skin to skin with the help of my husband and nurses, and breastfeed in recovery. Their bedside manner is second to none, and aftercare is just as good. I see their NP, Sara, for my mental healthcare, and she is wonderful. Thank you for all you do for women and babies, FMCC!
Michelle Gresham
January 6th, 2026
My first encounter with Dr. Stroud was nearly 13 years ago, as a birth photographer, before the days of Fertility & Midwifery Care Center and Holy Family Birth Center. He was the OB on call for one of my mamas in labor, and while I was relatively new to birth work, I knew right away that there was something different and special about him. Unlike other obstetricians I had worked alongside, he was patient and unrushed. He quietly and calmly sat at my client’s bedside. He spoke gently and never disturbed the mother’s laboring environment. Instead of authoritative coached pushing, he patiently waited as she birthed her baby the way she needed to, all while giving her the encouragement she needed to bring her baby out. I was so impressed by his bedside manner and the way he respected my client’s wishes. I had never experienced a birth like that with another obstetrician - ever! I thought to myself, “He practices more like a midwife than an OB.”
Fast forward to 2020, as a seasoned birth photographer, and now doula, having worked alongside the FMCC providers for many years. I decided to make the switch to their practice for my fifth pregnancy, and I could not have been happier with my care. My pregnancy was very challenging, with intermittent bleeding into my second trimester as well as vomiting throughout the whole nine months of pregnancy. They went above and beyond to care for me and my baby! They allowed me to come into the office for ultrasounds and doppler checks to hear our baby’s heartbeat, to ease my anxious mind. They also referred me to an IV clinic for fluids and medication for the unrelenting vomiting, which had never been offered in my previous pregnancies. I didn’t even know that an IV clinic was an option! It made a world of difference and helped keep me afloat throughout my pregnancy. While I originally intended to deliver at Holy Family Birth Center, after much prayer and consideration, I made the difficult decision at the end of my pregnancy to birth in the hospital. Even though all of my babies had been born unmedicated, I needed the safety net of the hospital in the event I needed an epidural for the first time. My body felt too tired and too weak to get through labor. Even though I did manage to achieve another unmedicated birth, I felt my choices were respected and honored to make the switch.
After our fifth baby was born, my husband and I were certain that our baby days were over - our hearts and hands were full! - until a surprise pregnancy in 2023. While unexpected, we quickly became excited and immediately loved our sweet growing baby. Unfortunately, almost as soon as we found out about our new little one, we learned we lost him or her. Having never had a miscarriage before, it was truly one of the most painful and traumatic events I have ever experienced. FMCC was there through it all - praying for us, supporting us, and encouraging us. Even though our loss was early, it didn’t matter - the providers at FMCC acknowledge each new life from the moment they are conceived, knowing full well they are designed and loved by a Holy God. Even though our baby’s life was brief, they brought purpose into our family.
Heartbreakingly, we went on to lose three more babies. I cannot even begin to express the gratitude I have for the FMCC team for their deep compassion and empathy. As a grieving mother, it meant everything to me. They came alongside us during some of our darkest moments and helped carry the weight of our sadness and grief. We learned in between those losses that I have MTHFR, so we got progesterone and other medications on board… and because of Dr. Stroud’s help, we got to our perfect and precious rainbow baby, where he was welcomed into the world at Holy Family Birth Center, with the most incredible support team imaginable. HFBC is such a sacred, special place for birthing women and their families. Some of our older children were in attendance for their baby brother’s birth - it was an amazing and beautiful experience for them!
We love you, FMCC and HFBC! We will always be grateful for you!
Jennifer G
December 19th, 2025
This review does not reflect Dr. Stroud or his care. Dr. Stroud is an exceptional OBGYN. He delivered both of my children, and each experience was outstanding. He is compassionate, highly skilled, and attentive, and I will continue to confidently refer patients to him. He is truly one of the best in the area.
I am extremely disappointed with the care I received at this office from Dr. Cly. I came to him with a fibroid causing massive and ongoing blood loss that severely impacted my ability to function day to day. I was often confined to bed just to slow the bleeding, and my hemoglobin levels were repeatedly in the critical range. It got so bad I was sent to the ER for a blood transfusion.
Despite the seriousness of my condition, my concerns did not seem to be taken seriously. I was prescribed medication intended to thicken my blood, even though my lab results showed abnormal D-dimer levels, which made this approach feel unsafe and alarming. (I went to a new doctor and he told me not to take any of the medications.) There was no sense of urgency given the ongoing blood loss and the clear impact it was having on me.
To make matters worse, I was told surgery could not be scheduled until April — roughly six months later — despite my continued decline. At that point, I sought a second opinion.
The difference was immediate and striking. The new doctor immediately recognized the severity of my condition and worked to get me into surgery as soon as possible. That alone confirmed what I had felt all along: my situation required urgent care.
I am sharing this review because patients deserve to be heard and taken seriously, especially when dealing with conditions that can become life-threatening. I would strongly encourage others to advocate for themselves and seek a second opinion if they feel their concerns are being dismissed.
Bri Bowers
November 8th, 2025
I’ve heard amazing things about this practice. After many failed attempts at HRT I gave them a try. I felt very encouraged and excited after talking with Dr. Cly. However, after I received pellet therapy I was greatly discouraged. It’s wonderful for many. A game changer. But my experience was horrendous. Despite androgynous symptoms and extreme anxiety, I was told my T was too low and my E was causing the symptoms. Bloodwork didn’t show my T low. Raising T with already androgynous symptoms seemed like a wrong move to me so I declined. I was also told by the NP that women without a uterus don’t need progesterone. When I mentioned that even men have it she looked at me and said “no they don’t”. It was then that I felt let down- as this isn’t accurate. This is a very misguided script and I lost my faith in the practice for HRT. I feel like the NPs are pellet trained and the training in hormones comes from those scripts. I know the birth side of the practice is fabulous and I’ve heard so many good things from friends and family!
